| |
|
Ordering information
You can download the following documents from www.nice.org.uk/CG031
• The NICE guideline (this document) – all the recommendations.
• A quick reference guide, which has been distributed to healthcare
professionals working in the NHS in England.
• Information for people with OCD or BDD, their families and carers,
and the public.
• The full guideline – all the recommendations, details
of how they were developed, and summaries of the evidence on which they
were based.
For printed copies of the quick reference guide or information for the
public, phone the NHS Response Line on 0870 1555 455 and quote:
• N0919 (quick reference guide)
• N0920 (information for the public).
This guidance is written
in the following context
This guidance represents the view of the Institute, which was arrived
at after careful consideration of the evidence available. Healthcare
professionals are expected to take it fully into account when exercising
their clinical judgement. The guidance does not, however, override the
individual responsibility of health professionals to make decisions
appropriate to the circumstances of the individual patient, in consultation
with the patient and/or guardian or carer.
National Institute for Health
and Clinical Excellence
MidCity Place
71 High Holborn
London
WC1V 6NA
www.nice.org.uk
© Copyright National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence,
November 2005. All rights reserved. This material may be freely reproduced
for educational and not-for-profit purposes within the NHS. No reproduction
by or for commercial organisations is allowed without the express written
permission of the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence.
Contents
Introduction 4
Key priorities for implementation 5
1 Guidance 8
1.1 Principles of care for all people with OCD or BDD and their families
or carers 8
1.2 Stepped care for adults, young people and children with OCD or BDD
12
1.3 Step 1: awareness and recognition 13
1.4 Step 2: recognition and assessment 14
1.5 Steps 3-5: Treatment options for people with OCD or BDD 16
1.6 Step 6: intensive treatment and inpatient services for people with
OCD or BDD 35
1.7 Discharge after recovery 38
2 Notes on the scope of the guidance 39
3 Implementation in the NHS 40
3.1 Resource implications 40
3.2 General 40
3.3 Audit 40
4 Research recommendations 40
CBT treatment intensity formats among adults with OCD 41
5 Other versions of this guideline 43
5.1 Full guideline 43
5.2 Quick reference guide 43
5.3 Information for the public 43
6 Related NICE guidance 44
7 Review date 44
Appendix A: Grading scheme 45
Appendix B: The Guideline Development Group 46
Appendix C: The Guideline Review Panel 48
Appendix D: Technical detail on the criteria for audit 49
Introduction
Obsessive-compulsive disorder
(OCD) is characterised by the presence of either obsessions or compulsions,
but commonly both. The symptoms can cause significant functional impairment
and/or distress. An obsession is defined as an unwanted intrusive thought,
image or urge that repeatedly enters the person’s mind. Compulsions
are repetitive behaviours or mental acts that the person feels driven
to perform. A compulsion can either be overt and observable by others,
such as checking that a door is locked, or a covert mental act that
cannot be observed, such as repeating a certain phrase in one’s
mind.
It is thought that 1–2% of the population have OCD, although some
studies have estimated 2–3%.
Body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) is characterised by a preoccupation with
an imagined defect in one’s appearance, or in the case of a slight
physical anomaly, the person’s concern is markedly excessive.
BDD is characterised by time-consuming behaviours such as mirror gazing,
comparing particular features to those of others, excessive camouflaging
tactics to hide the defect, skin picking and reassurance seeking.
It is thought that 0.5–0.7% of the population have BDD.
Key priorities for implementation
All people with OCD or BDD
• Each PCT, mental healthcare trust and children’s trust
that provides mental health services should have access to a specialist
obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD)/body dysmorphic disorder (BDD) multidisciplinary
team offering age-appropriate care. This team would perform the following
functions: increase the skills of mental health professionals in the
assessment and evidence-based treatment of people with OCD or BDD, provide
high-quality advice, understand family and developmental needs, and,
when appropriate, conduct expert assessment and specialist cognitive-behavioural
and pharmacological treatment.
• OCD and BDD can have
a fluctuating or episodic course, or relapse may occur after successful
treatment. Therefore, people who have been successfully treated and
discharged should be seen as soon as possible if re-referred with further
occurrences of OCD or BDD, rather than placed on a routine waiting list.
For those in whom there has been no response to treatment, care coordination
(or other suitable processes) should be used at the end of any specific
treatment programme to identify any need for continuing support and
appropriate services to address it.
Adults with OCD or BDD
• In the initial treatment of adults with OCD, low intensity psychological
treatments (including exposure and response prevention [ERP]) (up to
10 therapist hours per patient) should be offered if the patient’s
degree of functional impairment is mild and/or the patient expresses
a preference for a low intensity approach. Low intensity treatments
include:
? brief individual cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT) (including ERP)
using structured self-help materials
? brief individual CBT (including ERP) by telephone
? group CBT (including ERP) (note, the patient may be receiving more
than 10 hours of therapy in this format).
• Adults with OCD with mild functional impairment who are unable
to engage in low intensity CBT (including ERP), or for whom low intensity
treatment has proved to be inadequate, should be offered the choice
of either a course of a selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitor (SSRI)
or more intensive CBT (including ERP) (more than 10 therapist hours
per patient), because these treatments appear to be comparably efficacious.
• Adults with OCD with
moderate functional impairment should be offered the choice of either
a course of an SSRI or more intensive CBT (including ERP) (more than
10 therapist hours per patient), because these treatments appear to
be comparably efficacious.
• Adults with BDD with
moderate functional impairment should be offered the choice of either
a course of an SSRI or more intensive individual CBT (including ERP)
that addresses key features of BDD.
Children and young people
with OCD or BDD
• Children and young people with OCD with moderate to severe functional
impairment, and those with OCD with mild functional impairment for whom
guided self-help has been ineffective or refused, should be offered
CBT (including ERP) that involves the family or carers and is adapted
to suit the developmental age of the child as the treatment of choice.
Group or individual formats should be offered depending upon the preference
of the child or young person and their family or carers.
• Following multidisciplinary
review, for a child (aged 8–11 years) with OCD or BDD with moderate
to severe functional impairment, if there has not been an adequate response
to CBT (including ERP) involving the family or carers, the addition
of an SSRI to ongoing psychological treatment may be considered. Careful
monitoring should be undertaken, particularly at the beginning of treatment.
• Following multidisciplinary
review, for a young person (aged 12–18 years) with OCD or BDD
with moderate to severe functional impairment if there has not been
an adequate response to CBT (including ERP) involving the family or
carers, the addition of an SSRI to ongoing psychological treatment should
be offered. Careful monitoring should be undertaken, particularly at
the beginning of treatment.
• All children and
young people with BDD should be offered CBT (including ERP) that involves
the family or carers and is adapted to suit the developmental age of
the child or young person as first-line treatment.
The following guidance is
evidence based. The grading scheme used for the recommendations (A,
B, C or good practice point GPP) is described in Appendix A; a summary
of the evidence on which the guidance is based is provided in the full
guideline (see Section 5).
1 Guidance
1.1 Principles of care for all people with OCD or BDD and their families
or carers
1.1.1 Understanding
1.1.1.1 People with OCD or BDD are often ashamed and embarrassed by
their condition and may find it very difficult to discuss their symptoms
with healthcare professionals, friends, family or carers. Healthcare
professionals should help patients, and their families or carers where
appropriate, to understand the involuntary nature of the symptoms by
providing accurate information in an appropriate format on current understanding
of the disorders from psychological and/or biological perspectives.
GPP
1.1.1.2 When assessing people with OCD or BDD, healthcare professionals
should sensitively explore the hidden distress and disability commonly
associated with the disorders, providing explanation and information
wherever necessary. In particular, people with OCD who are distressed
by their obsessive thoughts should be informed that such thoughts are
occasionally experienced by almost everybody, and when frequent and
distressing are a typical feature of OCD. GPP
1.1.2 Continuity of care
1.1.2.1 OCD and BDD are frequently recurring or chronic conditions that
often affect some of the most intimate aspects of a person’s life.
Healthcare professionals should therefore ensure continuity of care
and minimise the need for multiple assessments by different healthcare
professionals. GPP
1.1.2.2 Because OCD and BDD may occur across a person’s lifespan,
particular care should be given to the provision of appropriate care
at all ages and a seamless transition between services aimed at specific
ages, such as the transition from services for young people to services
for adults. GPP
1.1.2.3 Careful consideration should be given to the effective integration
and coordination of care of people with OCD and BDD across both primary
and secondary care. There should be clear, written agreement among individual
healthcare professionals about the responsibility for monitoring and
treating people with OCD and BDD. A written copy of this agreement should
be given to the patient. This should be in collaboration with the patient,
and where appropriate: GPP
• the Care Programme Approach (CPA) should be used
• the patient’s family or carers should be involved
• healthcare professionals should liaise with other professionals
involved in providing care and support to the patient.
1.1.3 Information and support
1.1.3.1 Treatment and care should take into account the individual needs
and preferences of people with OCD or BDD. Patients should have the
opportunity to make informed decisions about their care and treatment.
Where patients do not have the capacity to make decisions, or children
or young people are not old enough to do so, healthcare professionals
should follow the Department of Health guidelines (Reference guide to
consent for examination or treatment [2001]; available from www.dh.gov.uk).
GPP
1.1.3.2 Good communication between healthcare professionals and people
with OCD or BDD is essential. Provision of information, treatment and
care should be tailored to the needs of the individual, culturally appropriate,
and provided in a form that is accessible to people who have additional
needs, such as learning difficulties, physical or sensory disabilities,
or limited competence in speaking or reading English. GPP
1.1.3.3 Healthcare professionals should consider informing people with
OCD or BDD and their family or carers about local self-help and support
groups, and encourage them to participate in such groups where appropriate.
GPP
1.1.4 Religion and culture
1.1.4.1 Obsessive-compulsive symptoms may sometimes involve a person’s
religion, such as religious obsessions and scrupulosity, or cultural
practices. When the boundary between religious or cultural practice
and obsessive-compulsive symptoms is unclear, healthcare professionals
should, with the patient’s consent, consider seeking the advice
and support of an appropriate religious or community leader to support
the therapeutic process. GPP
1.1.5 Families and carers
1.1.5.1 Because OCD and BDD often have an impact on families and carers,
healthcare professionals should promote a collaborative approach with
people with OCD or BDD and their family or carers, wherever this is
appropriate and possible. GPP
1.1.5.2 In the treatment and care of people with OCD or BDD, family
members or carers should be provided with good information (both verbal
and written) about the disorder, its likely causes, its course and its
treatment. GPP
1.1.5.3 Assessment and treatment plans for people with OCD or BDD should,
where appropriate, involve relevant family members or carers. In some
cases, particularly with children and young people, when the symptoms
of OCD or BDD interfere with academic or workplace performance, it may
be appropriate to liaise with professionals from these organisations.
Assessment should include the impact of rituals and compulsions on others
(in particular on dependent children) and the degree to which carers
are involved in supporting or carrying out behaviours related to the
disorder. GPP
1.1.5.4 If dependent children are considered to be at risk of emotional,
social or mental health problems as a result of the behaviour of a parent
with OCD or BDD and/or the child’s involvement in related activity,
independent assessment of the child should be requested. If this is
carried out, the parent should be kept informed at every stage of the
assessment. GPP
1.1.5.5 In the treatment of people with OCD or BDD, especially when
the disorder is moderate to severe or chronic, an assessment of their
carer’s social, occupational and mental health needs should be
offered. GPP
1.2 Stepped care for adults,
young people and children with OCD or BDD
The stepped-care model draws attention to the different needs of people
with OCD and BDD, depending on the characteristics of their disorder,
their personal and social circumstances, their age, and the responses
that are required from services. It provides a framework in which to
organise the provision of services in order to identify and access the
most effective interventions (see Figure 1).
Who is responsible for care? What is the focus? What do they do?
Step 6
Inpatient care or intensive treatment programmes
CAMHS Tier 4 OCD or BDD with
risk to life, severe self-neglect or severe distress or disability Reassess,
discuss options, care coordination, SSRI or clomipramine, CBT (including
ERP), or combination of SSRI or clomipramine and CBT (including ERP),
augmentation strategies, consider admission or special living arrangements
Step 5
Multidisciplinary care with expertise in OCD/BDD
CAMHS Tier 3 and 4 OCD or
BDD with significant comorbidity, or more severely impaired functioning
and/or treatment resistance, partial response or relapse Reassess, discuss
options.
For adults:
SSRI or clomipramine, CBT (including ERP), or combination of SSRI or
clomipramine and CBT (including ERP); consider care coordination, augmentation
strategies, admission, social care.
For children and young people:
CBT (including ERP), then consider combined treatments of CBT (including
ERP) with SSRI, alternative SSRI or clomipramine. For young people consider
referral to specialist services outside CAMHS if appropriate
Step 4
Multidisciplinary care in primary or secondary care
CAMHS Tier 2 and 3 OCD or
BDD with comorbidity or poor response to initial treatment Assess and
review, discuss options.
For adults:
CBT (including ERP), SSRI, alternative SSRI or clomipramine, combined
treatments.
For children and young people:
CBT (including ERP), then consider combined treatments of CBT (including
ERP) with SSRI, alternative SSRI or clomipramine.
Step 3
GP, primary care team, primary care mental health worker, family support
team
CAMHS Tier 1 and 2 Management
and initial treatment of OCD or BDD Assess and review, discuss options.
For adults according to impairment:
Brief individual CBT (including ERP) with self-help materials (for OCD),
individual or group CBT (including ERP), SSRI, or consider combined
treatments; consider involving the family/carers in ERP.
For children and young people:
Guided self-help (for OCD), CBT (including ERP), involve family/carers
and consider involving school.
Step 2
GP, practice nurses, school health advisors, health visitors, general
health settings (including hospitals)
CAMHS Tier 1 Recognition
and
assessment Detect, educate, discuss treatment options, signpost voluntary
support organisations, provide support to individuals/families/work/schools,
or refer to any of the appropriate levels.
Step 1
Individuals, public organisations, NHS
Awareness and
recognition Provide, seek and share information about OCD or BDD and
its impact on individuals and families/carers.
Figure 1 The stepped-care
model
Stepped care attempts to provide the most effective but least intrusive
treatments appropriate to a person’s needs. It assumes that the
course of the disorder is monitored and referral to the appropriate
level of care is made depending on the person’s difficulties.
Each step introduces additional interventions; the higher steps normally
assume interventions in the previous step have been offered and/or attempted,
but there are situations where an individual may be referred to any
appropriate level. The guidance follows the steps in the figure.
At all stages of assessment and treatment, families or carers should
be involved as appropriate. This is particularly important in the treatment
of children and young people with OCD or BDD where it may also be helpful
to involve others in their network, for example teachers, school health
advisors, educational psychologists, and educational social workers.
1.3 Step 1: awareness and recognition
Although the more common forms of OCD are likely to be recognised when
people report symptoms, less common forms of OCD and many cases of BDD
may remain unrecognised, sometimes for many years. Relatively few mental
health professionals or GPs have expertise in the recognition, assessment,
diagnosis and treatment of the less common forms of OCD and BDD.
1.3.1.1 Each PCT, mental healthcare trust and children’s trust
that provides mental health services should have access to a specialist
OCD/BDD multidisciplinary team offering age-appropriate care. This team
would perform the following functions: increase the skills of mental
health professionals in the assessment and evidence-based treatment
of people with OCD or BDD, provide high-quality advice, understand family
and developmental needs, and, when appropriate, conduct expert assessment
and specialist cognitive-behavioural and pharmacological treatment.
GPP
1.3.1.2 Specialist mental healthcare professionals in OCD or BDD should
collaborate with local and national voluntary organisations to increase
awareness and understanding of the disorders and improve access to high-quality
information about them. Such information should also be made available
to primary and secondary healthcare professionals, and to professionals
from other public services who may come into contact with people of
any age with OCD or BDD. GPP
1.3.1.3 Specialist OCD/BDD teams should collaborate with people with
OCD or BDD and their families or carers to provide training for all
mental health professionals, cosmetic surgeons and dermatology professionals.
GPP
1.4 Step 2: recognition and assessment
1.4.1 OCD
1.4.1.1 For people known to be at higher risk of OCD (such as individuals
with symptoms of depression, anxiety, alcohol or substance misuse, BDD
or an eating disorder), or for people attending dermatology clinics,
healthcare professionals should routinely consider and explore the possibility
of comorbid OCD by asking direct questions about possible symptoms such
as the following. C
• Do you wash or clean a lot?
• Do you check things a lot?
• Is there any thought that keeps bothering you that you would
like to get rid of but can not?
• Do your daily activities take a long time to finish?
• Are you concerned about putting things in a special order or
are you very upset by mess?
• Do these problems trouble you?
1.4.1.2 In people who have been diagnosed with OCD, healthcare professionals
should assess the risk of self-harm and suicide, especially if they
have also been diagnosed with depression. Part of the risk assessment
should include the impact of their compulsive behaviours on themselves
or others. Other comorbid conditions and psychosocial factors that may
contribute to risk should also be considered. GPP
1.4.1.3 If healthcare professionals are uncertain about the risks associated
with intrusive sexual, aggressive or death-related thoughts reported
by people with OCD, they should consult mental health professionals
with specific expertise in the assessment and management of OCD. These
themes are common in people with OCD at any age, and are often misinterpreted
as indicating risk. GPP
1.4.2 BDD
1.4.2.1 For people known to be at higher risk of BDD (such as individuals
with symptoms of depression, social phobia, alcohol or substance misuse,
OCD or an eating disorder), or for people with mild disfigurements or
blemishes who are seeking a cosmetic or dermatological procedure, healthcare
professionals should routinely consider and explore the possibility
of BDD. GPP
1.4.2.2 In the assessment of people at higher risk of BDD, the following
five questions should be asked to help identify individuals with BDD.
GPP
• Do you worry a lot about the way you look and wish you could
think about it less?
• What specific concerns do you have about your appearance?
• On a typical day, how many hours a day is your appearance on
your mind? (More than 1 hour a day is considered excessive.)
• What effect does it have on your life?
• Does it make it hard to do your work or be with friends?
1.4.2.3 People with suspected or diagnosed BDD seeking cosmetic surgery
or dermatological treatment should be assessed by a mental health professional
with specific expertise in the management of BDD. GPP
1.4.2.4 In people who have been diagnosed with BDD, healthcare professionals
should assess the risk of self-harm and suicide, especially if they
have also been diagnosed with depression. Other comorbid conditions
and psychosocial factors that may contribute to risk should also be
considered. GPP
1.4.2.5 All children and young people who have been diagnosed with BDD
should be assessed for suicidal ideation and a full risk assessment
should be carried out before treatment is undertaken. If risks are identified,
all professionals involved in primary and secondary care should be informed
and appropriate risk management strategies put into place. GPP
1.4.2.6 Specialist mental health professionals in BDD should work in
partnership with cosmetic surgeons and dermatologists to ensure that
an agreed screening system is in place to accurately identify people
with BDD and that agreed referral criteria have been established. They
should help provide training opportunities for cosmetic surgeons and
dermatologists to aid in the recognition of BDD. GPP
1.5 Steps 3–5: treatment options for people with OCD or BDD
Effective treatments for OCD and BDD should be offered at all levels
of the healthcare system. The difference in the treatments at the higher
levels will reflect increasing experience and expertise in the implementation
of a limited range of therapeutic options. For many people, initial
treatment may be best provided in primary care settings. However, people
with more impaired functioning, higher levels of comorbidity, or poor
response to initial treatment will require care from teams with greater
levels of expertise and experience in the management of OCD/BDD.
Irrespective of the level of care, the following recommendations should
be taken into account when selecting initial treatments for people with
OCD or BDD. The specific recommendations on how to provide these treatments
follow in the subsequent sections.
Regulatory authorities have identified that the use of SSRIs to treat
depression in children and young people may be associated with the appearance
of suicidal behaviour, self-harm or hostility, particularly at the beginning
of treatment. There is no clear evidence of an increased risk of self-harm
and suicidal thoughts in young adults aged 18 years or older. But individuals
mature at different rates and young adults are at a higher background
risk of suicidal behaviour than older adults. Hence, young adults treated
with SSRIs should be closely monitored as a precautionary measure. The
Committee on Safety of Medicine’s Expert Working Group on SSRIs,
at a meeting in February 2005, advised that it could not be ruled out
that the risk of suicidal behaviour, hostility and other adverse reactions
seen in the paediatric depression trials applies to use in children
or young people in all indications. Consequently, the recommendations
about the use of SSRIs for people of any age with OCD or BDD have taken
account of the position of regulatory authorities.
1.5.1 Initial treatment options
Adults
The intensity of psychological treatment has been defined as the hours
of therapist input per patient. By this definition, most group treatments
are defined as low intensity treatment (less than 10 hours of therapist
input per patient), although each patient may receive a much greater
number of hours of therapy.
1.5.1.1 In the initial treatment of adults with OCD, low intensity psychological
treatments (including ERP) (up to 10 therapist hours per patient) should
be offered if the patient’s degree of functional impairment is
mild and/or the patient expresses a preference for a low intensity approach.
Low intensity treatments include: C
• brief individual CBT (including ERP) using structured self-help
materials
• brief individual CBT (including ERP) by telephone
• group CBT (including ERP) (note, the patient may be receiving
more than 10 hours of therapy in this format).
1.5.1.2 Adults with OCD with mild functional impairment who are unable
to engage in low intensity CBT (including ERP), or for whom low intensity
treatment has proved to be inadequate, should be offered the choice
of either a course of an SSRI or more intensive CBT (including ERP)
(more than 10 therapist hours per patient), because these treatments
appear to be comparably efficacious. C
1.5.1.3 Adults with OCD with moderate functional impairment should be
offered the choice of either a course of an SSRI or more intensive CBT
(including ERP) (more than 10 therapist hours per patient), because
these treatments appear to be comparably efficacious. B
1.5.1.4 Adults with OCD with severe functional impairment should be
offered combined treatment with an SSRI and CBT (including ERP). C
1.5.1.5 Adults with BDD with mild functional impairment should be offered
a course of CBT (including ERP) that addresses key features of BDD in
individual or group formats. The most appropriate format should be jointly
decided by the patient and the healthcare professional. B
1.5.1.6 Adults with BDD with moderate functional impairment should be
offered the choice of either a course of an SSRI or more intensive individual
CBT (including ERP) that addresses key features of BDD. B
1.5.1.7 Adults with BDD with severe functional impairment should be
offered combined treatment with an SSRI and CBT (including ERP) that
addresses key features of BDD. C
Children and young people
1.5.1.8 For children and young people with OCD with mild functional
impairment, guided self-help may be considered in conjunction with support
and information for the family or carers. C
1.5.1.9 Children and young people with OCD with moderate to severe functional
impairment, and those with OCD with mild functional impairment for whom
guided self-help has been ineffective or refused, should be offered
CBT (including ERP) that involves the family or carers and is adapted
to suit the developmental age of the child as the treatment of choice.
Group or individual formats should be offered depending upon the preference
of the child or young person and their family or carers. B
1.5.1.10 All children and young people with BDD should be offered CBT
(including ERP) that involves the family or carers and is adapted to
suit the developmental age of the child or young person as first-line
treatment. C
1.5.1.11 If psychological treatment is declined by children or young
people with OCD or BDD and their families or carers, or they are unable
to engage in treatment, an SSRI may be considered with specific arrangements
for careful monitoring for adverse events. B
1.5.1.12 The co-existence of comorbid conditions, learning disorders,
persisting psychosocial risk factors such as family discord, or the
presence of parental mental health problems, may be factors if the child
or young person’s OCD or BDD is not responding to any treatment.
Additional or alternative interventions for these aspects should be
considered. The child or young person will still require evidence-based
treatments for his or her OCD or BDD. C
1.5.2 How to use psychological interventions
Training
1.5.2.1 All healthcare professionals offering psychological treatments
to people of all ages with OCD or BDD should receive appropriate training
in the interventions they are offering and receive ongoing clinical
supervision in line with the recommendations in Organising and Delivering
Psychological Therapies (Department of Health, 2004) . GPP
Adults
1.5.2.2 For adults with obsessive thoughts who do not have overt compulsions,
CBT (including exposure to obsessive thoughts and response prevention
of mental rituals and neutralising strategies) should be considered.
B
1.5.2.3 For adults with OCD, cognitive therapy adapted for OCD may be
considered as an addition to ERP to enhance long-term symptom reduction.
C
1.5.2.4 For adults with OCD living with their family or carers, involving
a family member or carer as a co-therapist in ERP should be considered
where this is appropriate and acceptable to those involved. B
1.5.2.5 For adults with OCD with more severe functional impairment who
are housebound, unable or reluctant to attend a clinic, or have significant
problems with hoarding, a period of home-based treatment may be considered.
C
1.5.2.6 For adults with OCD with more severe functional impairment who
are housebound and unable to undertake home-based treatment because
of the nature of their symptoms (such as contamination concerns or hoarding
that prevents therapists’ access to the patient’s home),
a period of CBT by telephone may be considered. C
1.5.2.7 For adults with OCD who refuse or cannot engage with treatments
that include ERP, individual cognitive therapy specifically adapted
for OCD may be considered. C
1.5.2.8 When adults with OCD request forms of psychological therapy
other than cognitive and/or behavioural therapies as a specific treatment
for OCD (such as psychoanalysis, transactional analysis, hypnosis, marital/couple
therapy) they should be informed that there is as yet no convincing
evidence for a clinically important effect of these treatments. C
1.5.2.9 When family members or carers of people with OCD or BDD have
become involved in compulsive behaviours, avoidance or reassurance seeking,
treatment plans should help them reduce their involvement in these behaviours
in a sensitive and supportive manner. GPP
1.5.2.10 Adults with OCD or BDD with significant functional impairment
may need access to appropriate support for travel and transport to allow
them to attend for their treatment. GPP
1.5.2.11 Towards the end of treatment, healthcare professionals should
inform adults with OCD or BDD about how the principles learned can be
applied to the same or other symptoms if they occur in the future. GPP
Children and young people
Psychological treatments for children and young people should be collaborative
and engage the family or carers. When using psychological treatments
for children or young people, healthcare professionals should consider
the wider context and other professionals involved with the individual.
The recommendations on the use of psychological interventions for adults
may also be considered, where appropriate.
1.5.2.12 In the cognitive-behavioural treatment of children and young
people with OCD or BDD, particular attention should be given to: GPP
• developing and maintaining a good therapeutic alliance with
the child or young person, as well as their family or carers
• maintaining optimism in both the child or young person and their
family or carers
• collaboratively identifying initial and subsequent treatment
targets with the child or young person
• actively engaging the family or carers in planning treatment
and in the treatment process, especially in ERP where, if appropriate
and acceptable, they may be asked to assist the child or young person
• encouraging the use of ERP if new or different symptoms emerge
after successful treatment
• liaising with other professionals involved in the child or young
person’s life, including teachers, social workers and other healthcare
professionals, especially when compulsive activity interferes with the
ordinary functioning of the child or young person
• offering one or more additional sessions if needed at review
appointments after completion of CBT.
1.5.2.13 In the psychological treatment of children and young people
with OCD or BDD, healthcare professionals should consider including
rewards in order to enhance their motivation and reinforce desired behaviour
changes. C
1.5.3 How to use pharmacological interventions in adults
Current published evidence suggests that SSRIs are effective in treating
adults with OCD or BDD, although evidence for the latter is limited
and less certain. However, SSRIs may increase the risk of suicidal thoughts
and self-harm in people with depression and in younger people. It is
currently unclear whether there is an increased risk for people with
OCD or BDD. Regulatory authorities recommend caution in the use of SSRIs
until evidence for differential safety has been demonstrated.
Starting the treatment
1.5.3.1 Common concerns about taking medication for OCD or BDD should
be addressed. Patients should be advised, both verbally and with written
material, that:
• craving and tolerance do not occur C
• there is a risk of discontinuation/withdrawal symptoms on stopping
the drug, missing doses, or reducing the dose C
• there is a range of potential side effects, including worsening
anxiety, suicidal thoughts and self-harm, which need to be carefully
monitored, especially in the first few weeks of treatment C
• there is commonly a delay in the onset of effect of up to 12
weeks, although depressive symptoms improve more quickly C
• taking medication should not be seen as a weakness. GPP
Monitoring risk
1.5.3.2 Adults with OCD or BDD started on SSRIs who are not considered
to be at increased risk of suicide or self-harm should be monitored
closely and seen on an appropriate and regular basis. The arrangements
for monitoring should be agreed by the patient and the healthcare professional,
and recorded in the notes. GPP
1.5.3.3 Because of the potential increased risk of suicidal thoughts
and self-harm associated with the early stages of SSRI treatment, younger
adults (younger than age 30 years) with OCD or BDD, or people with OCD
or BDD with comorbid depression, or who are considered to be at an increased
risk of suicide, should be carefully and frequently monitored by healthcare
professionals. Where appropriate, other carers – as agreed by
the patient and the healthcare professional – may also contribute
to the monitoring until the risk is no longer considered significant.
The arrangements for monitoring should be agreed by the patient and
the healthcare professional, and recorded in the notes. C
1.5.3.4 For adults with OCD or BDD at a high risk of suicide, a limited
quantity of medication should be prescribed. C
1.5.3.5 When adults with OCD or BDD, especially those with comorbid
depression, are assessed to be at a high risk of suicide, the use of
additional support such as more frequent direct contacts with primary
care staff or telephone contacts should be considered, particularly
during the first weeks of treatment. C
1.5.3.6 For adults with OCD or BDD, particularly in the initial stages
of SSRI treatment, healthcare professionals should actively seek out
signs of akathisia or restlessness, suicidal ideation and increased
anxiety and agitation. They should also advise patients to seek help
promptly if symptoms are at all distressing. C
1.5.3.7 Adults with OCD or BDD should be monitored around the time of
dose changes for any new symptoms or worsening of their condition. C
Choice of drug treatment
Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs)
1.5.3.8 For adults with OCD, the initial pharmacological treatment should
be one of the following SSRIs: fluoxetine, fluvoxamine, paroxetine,
sertraline or citalopram . A
1.5.3.9 For adults with BDD (including those with beliefs of delusional
intensity), the initial pharmacological treatment should be fluoxetine
because there is more evidence for its effectiveness in BDD than there
is for other SSRIs. B
1.5.3.10 In the event that an adult with OCD or BDD develops marked
and/or prolonged akathisia, restlessness or agitation while taking an
SSRI, the use of the drug should be reviewed. If the patient prefers,
the drug should be changed to a different SSRI. C
1.5.3.11 Healthcare professionals should be aware of the increased risk
of drug interactions when prescribing an SSRI to adults with OCD or
BDD who are taking other medications. GPP
1.5.3.12 For adults with OCD or BDD, if there has been no response to
a full course of treatment with an SSRI, healthcare professionals should
check that the patient has taken the drug regularly and in the prescribed
dose and that there is no interference from alcohol or substance use.
GPP
1.5.3.13 For adults with OCD or BDD, if there has not been an adequate
response to a standard dose of an SSRI, and there are no significant
side effects after 4–6 weeks, a gradual increase in dose should
be considered in line with the schedule suggested by the Summary of
Product Characteristics. C
1.5.3.14 For adults with OCD or BDD, the rate at which the dose of an
SSRI should be increased should take into account therapeutic response,
adverse effects and patient preference. Patients should be warned about,
and monitored for, the emergence of side effects during dose increases.
GPP
1.5.3.15 If treatment for OCD or BDD with an SSRI is effective, it should
be continued for at least 12 months to prevent relapse and allow for
further improvements. C
1.5.3.16 When an adult with OCD or BDD has taken an SSRI for 12 months
after remission (symptoms are not clinically significant and the person
is fully functioning for at least 12 weeks), healthcare professionals
should review with the patient the need for continued treatment. This
review should consider the severity and duration of the initial illness,
the number of previous episodes, the presence of residual symptoms,
and concurrent psychosocial difficulties. GPP
1.5.3.17 If treatment for OCD or BDD with an SSRI is continued for an
extended period beyond 12 months after remission (symptoms are not clinically
significant and the person is fully functioning for at least 12 weeks),
the need for continuation should be reviewed at regular intervals, agreed
between the patient and the prescriber, and written in the notes. GPP
1.5.3.18 For adults with OCD or BDD, to minimise discontinuation/withdrawal
symptoms when reducing or stopping SSRIs, the dose should be tapered
gradually over several weeks according to the person’s need. The
rate of reduction should take into account the starting dose, the drug
half-life and particular profiles of adverse effects. C
1.5.3.19 Healthcare professionals should encourage adults with OCD or
BDD who are discontinuing SSRI treatment to seek advice if they experience
significant discontinuation/withdrawal symptoms. C
Other drugs
1.5.3.20 The following drugs should not normally be used to treat OCD
or BDD without comorbidity: C
• tricyclic antidepressants other than clomipramine
• tricyclic-related antidepressants
• serotonin and noradrenaline re-uptake inhibitors (SNRIs), including
venlafaxine
• monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs)
• anxiolytics (except cautiously for short periods to counter
the early activation of SSRIs).
1.5.3.21 Antipsychotics as a monotherapy should not normally be used
for treating OCD. C
1.5.3.22 Antipsychotics as a monotherapy should not normally be used
for treating BDD (including beliefs of delusional intensity). C
1.5.4 Poor response to initial treatment in adults
If initial treatment does not result in a clinically significant improvement
in both symptoms and functioning, other treatment options should be
considered. When additional treatment options also fail to produce an
adequate response, multidisciplinary teams with specific expertise in
OCD/BDD should become involved. Their role should include supporting
and collaborating with those professionals already involved in an individual’s
care.
1.5.4.1 For adults with OCD or BDD, if there has not been an adequate
response to treatment with an SSRI alone (within 12 weeks) or CBT (including
ERP) alone (more than 10 therapist hours per patient), a multidisciplinary
review should be carried out. GPP
1.5.4.2 Following multidisciplinary review, for adults with OCD or BDD,
if there has not been an adequate response to treatment with an SSRI
alone (within 12 weeks) or CBT (including ERP) alone (more than 10 therapist
hours per patient), combined treatment with CBT (including ERP) and
an SSRI should be offered. C
1.5.4.3 For adults with OCD or BDD, if there has not been an adequate
response after 12 weeks of combined treatment with CBT (including ERP)
and an SSRI, or there has been no response to an SSRI alone, or the
patient has not engaged with CBT, a different SSRI or clomipramine should
be offered. C
1.5.4.4 Clomipramine should be considered in the treatment of adults
with OCD or BDD after an adequate trial of at least one SSRI has been
ineffective or poorly tolerated, if the patient prefers clomipramine
or has had a previous good response to it. C
1.5.4.5 For adults with OCD or BDD, if there has been no response to
a full trial of at least one SSRI alone, a full trial of combined treatment
with CBT (including ERP) and an SSRI, and a full trial of clomipramine
alone, the patient should be referred to a multidisciplinary team with
specific expertise in the treatment of OCD/BDD for assessment and further
treatment planning. GPP
1.5.4.6 The assessment of adults with OCD or BDD referred to multidisciplinary
teams with specific expertise in OCD/BDD should include a comprehensive
assessment of their symptom profile, previous pharmacological and psychological
treatment history, adherence to prescribed medication, history of side
effects, comorbid conditions such as depression, suicide risk, psychosocial
stressors, relationship with family and/or carers and personality factors.
GPP
1.5.4.7 Following multidisciplinary review, for adults with OCD if there
has been no response to a full trial of at least one SSRI alone, a full
trial of combined treatment with CBT (including ERP) and an SSRI, and
a full trial of clomipramine alone, the following treatment options
should also be considered (note, there is no evidence of the optimal
sequence of the options listed below): C
• additional CBT (including ERP) or cognitive therapy
• adding an antipsychotic to an SSRI or clomipramine
• combining clomipramine and citalopram.
1.5.4.8 Following multidisciplinary review, for adults with BDD, if
there has been no response to a full trial of at least one SSRI alone,
a full trial of combined treatment with CBT (including ERP) and an SSRI,
and a full trial of clomipramine alone, the following treatment options
should also be considered (note, there is no evidence of the optimal
sequence of the options listed below):
• additional CBT or cognitive therapy by a different multidisciplinary
team with expertise in BDD GPP
• adding buspirone to an SSRI. C
1.5.4.9 For adults with BDD, if there has been no response to treatment,
or the patient is not receiving appropriate treatment, more intensive
monitoring is needed because the risk of suicide is high in people with
BDD. GPP
1.5.4.10 Treatments such as combined antidepressants and antipsychotic
augmentation should not be routinely initiated in primary care. GPP
How to use clomipramine in adults
1.5.4.11 For adults with OCD or BDD who are at a significant risk of
suicide, healthcare professionals should only prescribe small amounts
of clomipramine at a time because of its toxicity in overdose . The
patient should be monitored regularly until the risk of suicide has
subsided. GPP
1.5.4.12 An electrocardiogram (ECG) should be carried out and a blood
pressure measurement taken before prescribing clomipramine for adults
with OCD or BDD at significant risk of cardiovascular disease. C
1.5.4.13 For adults with OCD or BDD, if there has not been an adequate
response to the standard dose of clomipramine, and there are no significant
side effects, a gradual increase in dose should be considered in line
with the schedule suggested by the Summary of Product Characteristics.
C
1.5.4.14 For adults with OCD or BDD, treatment with clomipramine should
be continued for at least 12 months if it appears to be effective and
because there may be further improvement. B
1.5.4.15 For adults with OCD or BDD, when discontinuing clomipramine,
doses should be reduced gradually in order to minimise potential discontinuation/withdrawal
symptoms. C
1.5.5 Poor response to initial treatment in children and young people
Current published evidence suggests that SSRIs are effective in treating
children and young people with OCD. The only SSRIs licensed for use
in children and young people with OCD are fluvoxamine and sertraline.
When used as a treatment for depression, SSRIs can cause significant
adverse reactions, including increased suicidal thoughts and risk of
self-harm, but it is not known whether this same risk occurs with their
use in OCD. SSRIs may be safer in depression when combined with psychological
treatments (see the NICE guideline Depression in children and young
people, available from www.nice.org.uk/CG028). Given that the UK regulatory
authority has advised that similar adverse reactions cannot be ruled
out in OCD, appropriate caution should be observed, especially in the
presence of comorbid depression.
1.5.5.1 For a child or young person with OCD or BDD, if there has not
been an adequate response within 12 weeks to a full trial of CBT (including
ERP) involving the family or carers, a multidisciplinary review should
be carried out. GPP
1.5.5.2 Following multidisciplinary review, for a child (aged 8–11
years) with OCD or BDD with moderate to severe functional impairment,
if there has not been an adequate response to CBT (including ERP) involving
the family or carers, the addition of an SSRI to ongoing psychological
treatment may be considered. Careful monitoring should be undertaken,
particularly at the beginning of treatment. C
1.5.5.3 Following multidisciplinary review, for a young person (aged
12–18 years) with OCD or BDD with moderate to severe functional
impairment, if there has not been an adequate response to CBT (including
ERP) involving the family or carers, the addition of an SSRI to ongoing
psychological treatment should be offered. Careful monitoring should
be undertaken, particularly at the beginning of treatment. B
1.5.5.4 For a child or a young person with OCD or BDD, if treatment
with an SSRI in combination with CBT (including ERP) involving the family
or carers is unsuccessful or is not tolerated because of side effects,
the use of another SSRI or clomipramine with careful monitoring may
be considered, especially if the child or young person has had a positive
response to these alternatives in the past. This should also be in combination
with CBT (including ERP). C
1.5.6 How to use pharmacological treatments in children and young people
In adults with OCD treated by medication, there is some clinical trial
evidence regarding the onset of therapeutic response, the dose needed,
the rate of increase of dose, the duration of treatment and the likelihood
of relapse on discontinuation. Trials of these aspects have not been
done in children and/or young people, but the following good practice
for prescribing SSRIs or clomipramine is based on adult trials and clinical
experience.
How to use SSRIs in children and young people
1.5.6.1 An SSRI should only be prescribed to children and young people
with OCD or BDD following assessment and diagnosis by a child and adolescent
psychiatrist who should also be involved in decisions about dose changes
and discontinuation. GPP
1.5.6.2 When an SSRI is prescribed to children and young people with
OCD or BDD, it should be in combination with concurrent CBT (including
ERP). If children and young people are unable to engage with concurrent
CBT, specific arrangements should be made for careful monitoring of
adverse events and these arrangements should be recorded in the notes.
C
1.5.6.3 Children and young people with OCD or BDD starting treatment
with SSRIs should be carefully and frequently monitored and seen on
an appropriate and regular basis. This should be agreed by the patient,
his or her family or carers and the healthcare professional, and recorded
in the notes. GPP
1.5.6.4 A licensed medication (sertraline or fluvoxamine ) should be
used when an SSRI is prescribed to children and young people with OCD,
except in patients with significant comorbid depression when fluoxetine
should be used, because of current regulatory requirements. A
1.5.6.5 Fluoxetine should be used when an SSRI is prescribed to children
and young people with BDD. C
1.5.6.6 For children and young people with OCD or BDD who also have
significant depression, the NICE recommendations for the treatment of
childhood depression should be followed and there should be specific
monitoring for suicidal thoughts or behaviours. GPP
1.5.6.7 Children and young people with OCD or BDD starting treatment
with SSRIs should be informed about the rationale for the drug treatment,
the delay in onset of therapeutic response (up to 12 weeks), the time
course of treatment, the possible side effects and the need to take
the medication as prescribed. Discussion of these issues should be supplemented
by written information appropriate to the needs of the child or young
person and their family or carers. GPP
1.5.6.8 The starting dose of medication for children and young people
with OCD or BDD should be low, especially in younger children. A half
or quarter of the normal starting dose may be considered for the first
week. C
1.5.6.9 If a lower dose of medication for children and young people
with OCD or BDD is ineffective, the dose should be increased until a
therapeutic response is obtained, with careful and close monitoring
for adverse events. The rate of increase should be gradual and should
take into account the delay in therapeutic response (up to 12 weeks)
and the age of the patient. Maximum recommended doses for children and
young people should not be exceeded. C
1.5.6.10 Children and young people prescribed an SSRI, and their families
or carers, should be informed by the prescribing doctor about the possible
appearance of suicidal behaviour, self-harm or hostility, particularly
at the beginning of treatment. They should be advised that if there
is any sign of new symptoms of these kinds, they should make urgent
contact with their medical practitioner. GPP
1.5.6.11 Where children or young people with OCD or BDD respond to treatment
with an SSRI, medication should be continued for at least 6 months post-remission
(that is, symptoms are not clinically significant and the child or young
person is fully functioning for at least 12 weeks). C
How to use clomipramine in children and young people
1.5.6.12 Children and young people with OCD or BDD and their families
or carers should be advised about the possible side effects of clomipramine,
including toxicity in overdose. C
1.5.6.13 Before starting treatment with clomipramine in children and
young people with OCD or BDD, an ECG should be carried out to exclude
cardiac conduction abnormalities. C
1.5.6.14 For a child or young person with OCD or BDD, if there has not
been an adequate response to the standard dose of clomipramine, and
there are no significant side effects, a gradual increase in dose may
be cautiously considered. C
1.5.6.15 Treatment of a child or young person with OCD or BDD with clomipramine
should be continued for at least 6 months if the treatment appears to
be effective, because there may be further improvement in symptoms.
B
Stopping or reducing SSRIs and clomipramine in children and young people
1.5.6.16 In children and young people with OCD or BDD, an attempt should
be made to withdraw medication if remission has been achieved (that
is, symptoms are no longer clinically significant and the child or young
person is fully functioning) and maintained for at least 6 months, and
if that is their wish. Patients and their family or carers should be
warned that relapse and/or discontinuation/withdrawal symptoms may occur.
They should be advised to contact their medical practitioner should
symptoms of discontinuation/withdrawal arise. C
1.5.6.17 For children and young people with OCD or BDD, to minimise
discontinuation/withdrawal symptoms on reducing or stopping antidepressants,
particularly SSRIs, the dose should be tapered gradually over several
weeks according to the individual’s need. The rate of reduction
should take into account the starting dose, the drug half-life and particular
profiles of adverse effects. C
1.5.6.18 Children and young people with OCD or BDD should continue with
psychological treatment throughout the period of drug discontinuation
because this may reduce the risk of relapse. C
Other drugs
1.5.6.19 Tricyclic antidepressants other than clomipramine should not
be used to treat OCD or BDD in children and young people. C
1.5.6.20 Other antidepressants (MAOIs, SNRIs) should not be used to
treat OCD or BDD in children and young people. C
1.5.6.21 Antipsychotics should not be used alone in the routine treatment
of OCD or BDD in children or young people, but may be considered as
an augmentation strategy. C
1.6 Step 6: intensive treatment and inpatient services for people with
OCD or BDD
1.6.1.1 People with severe, chronic, treatment-refractory OCD or BDD
should have continuing access to specialist treatment services staffed
by multidisciplinary teams of healthcare professionals with expertise
in the management of the disorders. C
1.6.1.2 Inpatient services, with specific expertise in OCD and BDD,
are appropriate for a small proportion of people with these disorders,
and may be considered when: GPP
• there is risk to life
• there is severe self-neglect
• there is extreme distress or functional impairment
• there has been no response to adequate trials of pharmacological/psychological/combined
treatments over long periods of time in other settings
• a person has additional diagnoses, such as severe depression,
anorexia nervosa or schizophrenia, that make outpatient treatment more
complex
• a person has a reversal of normal night/day patterns that make
attendance at any daytime therapy impossible
• the compulsions and avoidance behaviour are so severe or habitual
that they cannot undertake normal activities of daily living.
1.6.1.3 A small minority of adults with long-standing and disabling
obsessive-compulsive symptoms that interfere with daily living and have
prevented them from developing a normal level of autonomy may, in addition
to treatment, need suitable accommodation in a supportive environment
that will enable them to develop life skills for independent living.
GPP
1.6.1.4 Neurosurgery is not recommended in the treatment of OCD. However,
if a patient requests neurosurgery because they have severe OCD that
is refractory to other forms of treatment, the following should be taken
into consideration. GPP
• Existing published criteria (such as Matthews and Eljamel, 2003
) should be used to guide decisions about suitability.
• Multidisciplinary teams with a high degree of expertise in the
pharmacological and psychological treatment of OCD should have been
recently involved in the patient’s care. All pharmacological options
should have been considered and every attempt should have been made
to engage the individual in CBT (including ERP) and cognitive therapy,
including very intensive and/or inpatient treatments.
• Standardised assessment protocols should be used pre- and post-operation
and at medium- and long-term follow-ups in order to audit the interventions.
These assessment protocols should include standardised measures of symptoms,
quality of life, social and personality function, as well as comprehensive
neuropsychological tests.
• Services offering assessment for neurosurgical treatments should
have access to independent advice on issues such as adequacy of previous
treatment and consent and should be subject to appropriate oversight.
• Post-operative care should be carefully considered, including
pharmacological and psychological therapies.
• Services offering assessment for neurosurgical treatments should
be committed to sharing and publishing audit information.
1.6.1.5 For children and young people with severe OCD or BDD with high
levels of distress and/or functional impairment, if there has been no
response to adequate treatment in outpatient settings, or there is significant
self-neglect or risk of suicide, assessment for intensive inpatient
treatment in units where specialist treatment for children or young
people with OCD or BDD is available should be offered. GPP
1.7 Discharge after recovery
1.7.1.1 When a person of any age with OCD or BDD is in remission (symptoms
are not clinically significant and the person is fully functioning for
12 weeks), he or she should be reviewed regularly for 12 months by a
mental health professional. The exact frequency of contact should be
agreed between the professional and the person with OCD or BDD and/or
the family and/or carer and recorded in the notes. At the end of the
12-month period if recovery is maintained the person can be discharged
to primary care. C
1.7.1.2 OCD and BDD can have a fluctuating or episodic course, or relapse
may occur after successful treatment. Therefore, people who have been
successfully treated and discharged should be seen as soon as possible
if re-referred with further occurrences of OCD or BDD, rather than placed
on a routine waiting list. For those in whom there has been no response
to treatment, care coordination (or other suitable processes) should
be used at the end of any specific treatment programme to identify any
need for continuing support and appropriate services to address it.
GPP
2 Notes on the scope of the
guidance
All NICE guidelines are developed in accordance with a scope document
that defines what the guideline will and will not cover. The scope of
this guideline was established at the start of the development of this
guideline, following a period of consultation; it is available from
www.nice.org.uk/page.aspx?o=212178
This guideline is relevant to children, young people and adults diagnosed
with OCD or BDD, to their families and carers, and to all healthcare
professionals involved in the help, treatment and care of people with
OCD or BDD. These include the following.
• Professional groups who share in the treatment and care of people
diagnosed with OCD or BDD, including psychiatrists, clinical psychologists,
mental health nurses, community psychiatric nurses, social workers,
practice nurses, secondary care medical staff, paramedical staff, occupational
therapists, pharmacists, paediatricians, other physicians and general
medical professionals.
• Professionals in other health and non-health sectors who may
have direct contact with or are involved in the provision of health
and other public services for those diagnosed with OCD or BDD. These
may include prison doctors, the police and professionals who work in
the criminal justice and education sectors.
• Those with responsibility for planning services for people diagnosed
with OCD or BDD and their carers, including directors of public health,
NHS trust managers and managers in primary care trusts.
The guidance does not specifically address care and treatment not normally
available on the NHS.
3 Implementation in the NHS
3.1 Resource implications
Local health communities should review their existing practice for OCD
and BDD against this guideline. The review should consider the resources
required to implement the recommendations set out in Section 1, the
people and processes involved, and the timeline over which full implementation
is envisaged. It is in the interests of people with OCD and BDD that
implementation is as rapid as possible.
Relevant local clinical guidelines, care pathways and protocols should
be reviewed in the light of this guidance and revised accordingly.
Information on the cost impact of this guideline in England is available
on the NICE website and includes a template that local communities can
use (www.nice.org.uk/CG031costtemplate).
3.2 General
The Department of Health considers implementation of clinical guidelines
to be a developmental standard and this will be monitored by the Healthcare
Commission. The implementation of this guideline will build on the National
Service Framework for Mental Health in England and Wales and should
form part of the service development plans for each local health community
in England and Wales.
This guideline should be used in conjunction with the National Service
Framework for Mental Health, which is available from www.dh.gov.uk
3.3 Audit
Suggested audit criteria are listed in Appendix D, and can be used to
audit practice locally.
4 Research recommendations
The Guideline Development Group has made the following recommendations
for research, on the basis of its review of the evidence. The Group
regards these recommendations as the most important research areas to
improve NICE guidance and patient care in the future. The Guideline
Development Group’s full set of research recommendations is detailed
in the full guideline (see Section 5).
4.1 Treatment of OCD and BDD among young people and young adults
Appropriately blinded randomised controlled trials (RCTs) should be
conducted to assess the acute and long-term efficacy (including measures
of social function and quality of life), acceptability and the cost
effectiveness of CBT and SSRIs, alone and in combination, compared with
each other and with appropriate control treatments for both the psychological
and pharmacological arms. These should be carried out in a broadly based
sample of young people and young adults (for example, aged 12–25
years) diagnosed with OCD and BDD across a range of functional impairment
(using minimal exclusion criteria). The trials should be powered to
examine the effect of treatment for combined versus single-strand treatments
and involve a follow-up of 1, 2 and 5 years. Any treatment received
in the follow-up period should also be recorded.
4.2 CBT treatment intensity formats among adults with OCD
Appropriately blinded RCTs should be conducted to assess the efficacy
(including measures of social function and quality of life), acceptability
and the cost effectiveness of different delivery formats of CBT that
include ERP for adults with OCD, including brief individual CBT using
structured self-help materials, brief individual CBT by telephone, group
CBT and standard individual CBT compared with each other and with credible
psychological treatment that is not specific to OCD and BDD (such as
anxiety management training) in a broadly based sample of people diagnosed
with OCD across a range of functional impairment (using minimal exclusion
criteria). The trials should be powered to examine the effect of treatment
in different bands of severity or functional impairment and involve
a follow-up of 1 and 2 years. Any treatment received in the follow-up
period should also be recorded.
4.3 CBT for adults with OCD who have not responded to treatment
An appropriately blinded RCT should be conducted to assess the efficacy
(including measures of social functioning and quality of life as well
as OCD) of intensive versus spaced individual treatments (that include
both ERP and cognitive therapy elements) compared with a treatment-as-usual
control in a broadly based sample of adults diagnosed with OCD who have
not responded to one or more adequate trials of an SSRI or clomipramine
and one or more trials of CBT (that included ERP). The trial should
be powered to examine the relative efficacy of intensive versus spaced
treatment and involve a follow-up of 1 and 2 years. Any treatment received
in the follow-up period should also be recorded.
4.4 Screening for OCD and BDD
Appropriately designed studies should be conducted to compare validated
screening instruments for the detection of OCD and BDD in children,
young people and adults. An emphasis should be placed on examining those
that use computer technology and more age-appropriate methods of assessing
both symptoms and functioning, taking into account cultural and ethnic
variations in communication, and family values. For BDD, specific populations
would include young people or adults who consult in dermatology or plastic
surgery and those with other psychiatric disorders.
4.5 CBT for children and young people with OCD and BDD
An appropriately blinded RCT should be conducted to assess the efficacy
(including measures of social functioning and quality of life) and the
cost effectiveness of individual CBT and CBT involving the family or
carers compared with each other and with a credible psychological treatment
that is not specific to OCD and BDD (such as anxiety management training)
in a broadly based sample of children and young people diagnosed with
OCD and BDD (using minimal exclusion criteria). The trial should be
powered to examine the effect of treatment in children and young people
separately and involve a follow-up of at least 1 year.
5 Other versions of this guideline
The National Institute for Clinical Excellence commissioned the development
of this guidance from the National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health.
The Centre established a Guideline Development Group, which reviewed
the evidence and developed the recommendations. The members of the Guideline
Development Group are listed in Appendix B. Information about the independent
Guideline Review Panel is given in Appendix C.
The booklet The guideline development process – an overview for
stakeholders, the public and the NHS has more information about the
Institute’s guideline development process. It is available from
the Institute’s website and copies can also be ordered by telephoning
0870 1555 455 (quote reference N0472).
5.1 Full guideline
The full guideline, Obsessive-compulsive disorder: core interventions
in the treatment of obsessive-compulsive disorder and body dysmorphic
disorder, is published by the National Collaborating Centre for Mental
Health; it is available from (www.rcpsych.ac.uk), the NICE website (www.nice.org.uk/CG031fullguideline)
and the website of the National Library for Health (www.nlh.nhs.uk).
5.2 Quick reference guide
A quick reference guide for health professionals is also available from
the NICE website (www.nice.org/CG031quickrefguide) or from the NHS Response
Line (telephone 0870 1555 455; quote reference number N0919).
5.3 Information for the public
A version of this guideline for people with OCD or BDD and their carers,
and for the public, is available from the NICE website (www.nice.org.uk/CG031publicinfo)
or from the NHS Response Line (0870 1555 455); quote reference number
N0920.
5.4 Implementation tools
This guideline is supported by several implementation tools available
on our website from November 2005:
• a national costing report
• a local costing template
• implementation advice
• a slide set.
6 Related NICE guidance
Computerised cognitive behaviour therapy (CCBT) for the treatment of
depression and anxiety (review of existing NICE Technology Appraisal
No. 51). (Publication expected in early 2006.)
Depression: management of depression in primary and secondary care.
NICE Clinical Guideline No. 23 (2004). Available from www.nice.org/CG023
Depression in children: identification and management of depression
in children and young people in primary care and specialist services.
NICE Clinical Guideline No. 28 (2005). Available from www.nice.org.uk/CG028
Anxiety: management of anxiety (panic disorder, with or without agoraphobia,
and generalised anxiety disorder) in adults in primary, secondary and
community care. NICE Clinical Guideline No. 22 (2004). Available from
www.nice.org/CG022
7 Review date
The process of reviewing the evidence is expected to begin 4 years after
the date of issue of this guideline. Reviewing may begin earlier than
4 years if significant evidence that affects the guideline recommendations
is identified sooner. The updated guideline will be available within
2 years of the start of the review process.
Appendix A: Grading scheme
All evidence was classified according to an accepted hierarchy of evidence
that was originally adapted from the US Agency for Healthcare Policy
and Research Classification (see Box 1). Recommendations were then graded
A to C based on the level of associated evidence. This grading scheme
is based on a scheme formulated by the Clinical Outcomes Group of the
NHS Executive (1996).
Box 1: Hierarchy of evidence and recommendations grading scheme
Level Type of evidence Grade Evidence
I Evidence obtained from a single randomised controlled trial or a meta-analysis
of randomised controlled trials A At least one randomised controlled
trial as part of a body of literature of overall good quality and consistency
addressing the specific recommendation (evidence level I) without extrapolation
IIa Evidence obtained from at least one well-designed controlled study
without randomisation B Well-conducted clinical studies but no randomised
clinical trials on the topic of recommendation (evidence levels II or
III); or extrapolated from level I evidence
IIb Evidence obtained from at least one other well-designed quasi-experimental
study
III Evidence obtained from well-designed non-experimental descriptive
studies, such as comparative studies, correlation studies and case studies
IV Evidence obtained from expert committee reports or opinions and/or
clinical experiences of respected authorities C Expert committee reports
or opinions and/or clinical experiences of respected authorities (evidence
level IV) or extrapolated from level I or II evidence. This grading
indicates that directly applicable clinical studies of good quality
are absent or not readily available
GPP Recommended good practice based on the clinical experience of the
GDG.
Adapted from Eccles M, Mason J (2001) How to develop cost-conscious
guidelines. Health Technology Assessment 5:16 and Mann T (1996) Clinical
Guidelines: Using Clinical Guidelines to Improve Patient Care Within
the NHS. London: Department of Health.
Appendix B: The Guideline
Development Group
Professor Mark Freeston (Chair)
Professor of Clinical Psychology, University of Newcastle upon Tyne,
Newcastle, North Tyneside and Northumberland Mental Health NHS Trust
Dr Tim Kendall (Guideline Facilitator)
Co-Director, National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health, Deputy
Director, Royal College of Psychiatrists Research Unit, Consultant Psychiatrist
and Medical Director, Community Health Sheffield NHS Trust
Dr Jo Derisley
Chartered Clinical Psychologist, Norfolk & Waveney Mental Health
Partnership NHS Trust; Honorary Lecturer, University of East Anglia
Dr Naomi Fineberg
Consultant Psychiatrist, Queen Elizabeth II Hospital, Welwyn Garden
City
Ms Tracey Flannaghan
Nurse in practice, CBT Department, Glenfield Hospital, Leicester
Dr Isobel Heyman
Consultant Child and Adolescent Psychiatrist, Maudsley and Great Ormond
Street Hospitals, Children’s Department, Maudsley Hospital, London
Mr Richard Jenkins
Systematic Reviewer (2003–2004) The National Collaborating Centre
for Mental Health
Mr Christopher Jones
Health Economist, The National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health
Ms Gillian Knight
People with OCD, London
Dr Karina Lovell
Senior Lecturer, School of Nursing, Midwifery and Social Work, The University
of Manchester
Dr Catherine Pettinari
Senior Centre Project Manager, The National Collaborating Centre for
Mental Health
Ms Preethi Premkumar
Research Assistant, The National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health
Mr Cliff Snelling
Carers of People with OCD, Northampton
Dr Clare Taylor
Editor, The National Collaborating Centre for Mental Health
Mr Rowland Urey
People with OCD, Oldham
Dr David Veale
Consultant Psychiatrist in Cognitive Behaviour Therapy, The Priory Hospital
North London and the South London and Maudsley Trust; Honorary Senior
Lecturer, Institute of Psychiatry, King’s College London
Ms Heather Wilder
Information Scientist, The National Collaborating Centre for Mental
Health
Dr Craig Whittington
Senior Systematic Reviewer, The National Collaborating Centre for Mental
Health
Dr Steven Williams
General Practitioner, The Garth Surgery, Guisborough
Appendix C: The Guideline
Review Panel
The Guideline Review Panel is an independent panel that oversees the
development of the guideline and takes responsibility for monitoring
its quality. The Panel includes experts on guideline methodology, health
professionals and people with experience of the issues affecting patients
and carers. The members of the Guideline Review Panel were as follows.
Dr Chaand Nagpaul (Chair)
GP, Stanmore
Mr John Seddon
Patient Representative, Bolton
Professor Kenneth Wilson
Professor of Psychiatry of Old Age and Honorary Consultant Psychiatrist,
Cheshire and Wirral Partnership NHS Trust
Dr Paul Rowlands
Consultant Psychiatrist, Derbyshire Mental Health Services Mental Health
Care Trust
Dr Roger Paxton
R&D Director, Newcastle, North Tyneside and Northumberland Mental
Health NHS Trust
Dr Catriona McMahon
Medical Head, Specialist Care, AstraZeneca
Professor Shirley Reynolds
Professor of Medicine, Health Policy and Practice, University of East
Anglia
Appendix D: Technical detail on the criteria for audit
Possible objectives for an audit
One or more audits could be carried out in different care settings to
ensure that:
• individuals with OCD or BDD are involved in their care
• treatment options are appropriately offered and provided for
individuals with OCD or BDD.
People that could be included in an audit and time period for selection
A single audit could include all individuals with OCD or BDD. Alternatively,
individual audits could be undertaken on specific groups of individuals
such as:
• people with OCD or BDD at a particular stage (for example, to
study assessment)
• a sample of people with OCD or BDD from particular populations
in primary care.
Measures that could be used as a basis for an audit
Please see tables overleaf
1. Possible objective for
audit
To improve access to specialist OCD/BDD multidisciplinary healthcare
across the individual’s lifespan
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
Each PCT, mental healthcare trust, and children’s trust that provides
mental health services has access to a specialist multidisciplinary
OCD/BDD team.
a) Operational policies in each PCT, mental healthcare trust and children’s
trust that provides mental health services specify procedure for accessing
specialist OCD/BDD team
b) Specialist teams offer a liaison function to other mental health
professionals None A specialist OCD/BDD team is able to conduct expert
assessment, specialist cognitive-behavioural and pharmacological treatment
and provide age-appropriate care
A liaison function will aim
to: increase skills in the assessment and evidence-based treatment of
people with OCD or BDD; provide high-quality advice; aid understanding
of the needs of family/carers and developmental needs
2. Possible objective for audit
To decrease delays in the patient pathway for people who are re-referred
for treatment of OCD/BDD
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
People with OCD or BDD who have relapsed following successful treatment
are seen by a healthcare professional as soon as possible if re-referred,
and where there has been no response to treatment are appropriately
supported.
a) Operational policies indicate the re-referral pathway
b) Operational policies indicate that care coordination or other suitable
process is followed for people where there has been no response to treatment
Person with OCD or BDD refuses re-referral
None
3. Possible objective for audit
To improve the initial treatment of adults who have mild OCD or BDD,
or those who prefer a low intensity psychological treatment
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
In their initial treatment, adults who have mild OCD or BDD, or those
who express a preference, are offered a low intensity psychological
treatment.
a) Clinical notes indicate that people are informed of low intensity
treatment options
b) Clinical notes indicate the clinical outcome of low intensity interventions
• Adults with moderate to severe OCD or BDD
• Children and young people
• Adults who refuse this treatment Low intensity treatments (less
than 10 therapist hours) include:
• brief individual CBT (including ERP) using structured self-help
materials
• brief individual CBT (including ERP) by telephone
• group CBT (including ERP) – note the patient may be receiving
more than 10 hours of therapy in this format
4. Possible objective for audit
To improve the treatment of adults who have been unable to engage with,
or where there has been no response to, low intensity treatment
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
Where adults have been unable to engage with low intensity treatment,
or there has been no response to low intensity treatment, adults with
mild OCD are offered more intensive treatment interventions.
a) Clinical notes indicate that people have been informed of the possibility
of intensive CBT (including ERP) or an SSRI
b) Clinical notes indicate the clinical outcome of the intervention
offered
• Adults where there is improvement with low intensity interventions
• Children and young people
• Adults who refuse these treatments More intensive treatment
interventions include: a choice of either a course of an SSRI, or more
intensive CBT (including ERP) (of more than 10 therapist hours per patient)
5. Possible objective for audit
To improve the treatment of adults who have OCD with moderate functional
impairment
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
Adults who have OCD with moderate functional impairment are offered
the choice of either a course of an SSRI or more intensive CBT (including
ERP).
a) Clinical notes indicate that people have been informed of the possibility
of more intensive CBT (including ERP) or an SSRI
b) Clinical notes indicate the clinical outcome of the intervention
offered
Children and young people
More intensive CBT (including ERP) means: more than 10 therapist hours
per patient
6. Possible objective for audit
To improve the treatment of adults who have BDD with moderate functional
impairment
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
Adults who have moderate BDD are offered the choice of an SSRI or more
intensive individual CBT (including ERP) or an SSRI.
a) Clinical notes indicate that people have been informed of the possibility
of intensive individual CBT (including ERP) or an SSRI
b) Clinical notes indicate the clinical outcome of the intervention
offered Children and young people
CBT (including ERP) means: ERP that addresses key features of BDD.
7. Possible objective for audit
To improve the care of children and young people who have OCD with moderate
to severe functional impairment and those who have OCD with mild functional
impairment for whom guided self-help has been ineffective or refused
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
Children and young people who have OCD with moderate/severe impairment
or those with mild impairment where there is no response to guided self-help,
or where guided self-help has been refused, will be offered CBT (including
ERP) as the treatment of choice.
a) Clinical notes indicate that the child/young person and the family/carer
were informed of possibility of CBT
b) Clinical notes identify the clinical outcome of CBT Children and
young people who refuse CBT (including ERP) CBT (including ERP) means:
treatment involving the family or carers and adapted to suit the developmental
age of the child. Group or individual formats should be offered depending
upon the preference of the child or young person and their family or
carers
8. Possible objective for audit
To improve the care of children (aged 8–11 years) who have OCD
or BDD with moderate to severe functional impairment if there has not
been an adequate response to CBT (including ERP) involving the family
or carers
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
Children who have OCD or BDD where there has not been an adequate response
to CBT (including ERP) attend a multidisciplinary review (with family/carers)
where the use of an SSRI is considered in addition to ongoing psychological
treatment.
a) Clinical notes indicate a multidisciplinary review occurred and identified
that the use of an SSRI in addition to ongoing psychological treatment
was explored in detail
b) Clinical notes indicate that careful monitoring was carried out
c) Clinical notes indicate the clinical outcome of the intervention
offered Children who respond to CBT (including ERP)
Children: aged
8–11 years
Careful monitoring: being
seen frequently on an appropriate and regular basis agreed by the patient,
his or her family or carers and the healthcare professional, and recorded
in the notes
9. Possible objective for audit
To improve the treatment of young people (aged 12–18 years) who
have OCD or BDD with moderate to severe functional impairment if there
has not been an adequate response to CBT (including ERP) involving the
family or carers
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
Young people who have OCD or BDD where there has not been an adequate
response to CBT (including ERP) attend a multidisciplinary review (with
family/carers) where the use of an SSRI is considered in addition to
ongoing psychological treatment
a) Clinical notes indicate a multidisciplinary review occurred and identified
that the use of an SSRI in addition to ongoing psychological treatment
was explored in detail
b) Clinical notes indicate that careful monitoring was carried out
c) Clinical notes indicate the clinical outcome of the intervention
offered Young people who respond to CBT (including ERP)
Young people: aged 12–18 years
Careful monitoring: being
seen frequently on an appropriate and regular basis agreed by the patient,
his or her family or carers and the healthcare professional, and recorded
in the notes
10. Possible objective for audit
To improve the treatment of children and young people who have BDD
Criterion Exception Definition of terms
Children and young people with BDD are considered for CBT (including
ERP) as first-line treatment.
a) Clinical notes indicate that the healthcare professional responsible
has discussed the need for CBT (including ERP) and an arrangement has
been made
b) Clinical notes indicate the clinical outcome of the intervention
offered Children or young people who refuse treatment
Children: aged
8–11 years.
Young people: aged 12–18
years.
CBT (including ERP) means:
involving the family or carers and adapted to the developmental age
of the child or young person
|
|